At the beginning of his Constitution of Liberty (1960), the Nobel economist F.A. Hayek wrote the following dedication: “To the unknown civilization that is growing in America.” Civilization is an unfashionable word these days. It had, however, a specific meaning for Hayek.
In Hayek’s view, civilization concerns the emergence of norms, knowledge, institutions, and experiences over time that, taken together, could never be comprehended (let alone designed) by one person alone. What Hayek calls “higher civilization” embodies specific values such as liberty and personal responsibility but also protocols like free markets, rule of law, and constitutionalism.
Taken together, these values and institutions provide the possibility for every person to, according to Hayek, “transcend the boundaries of his ignorance by profiting from knowledge that he does not himself possess.” The full workings of the rule of law and constitutionalism are not known by the vast majority of people. Yet all of us make choices and act in certain ways because we know that the norms and protocols associated with such things are in place.
Hayek himself would have been the first to acknowledge that these insights about the nature of civilization were not original to him. He too was building on already-established foundations: in this case, that movement of ideas and individuals that we call the Scottish Enlightenment and, more particularly, its vision of a commercial civilization.
Action, Not Design
Associated with philosophers like Francis Hutcheson, David Hume, and Thomas Reid, political economists such as Adam Smith and Sir James Steuart, historians like Adam Ferguson and William Robertson, jurists such as Lord Kames and Lord Monboddo, scholars of rhetoric like Hugh Blair, and scientists such as Joseph Banks and James Hutton, the Scottish Enlightenment was part of that eighteenth-century outpouring of ideas across the West that reshaped the world in ways that still reverberate today.
Emerging out of ancient Scottish universities like Edinburgh, Glasgow, Aberdeen, and St Andrews, the Scottish experience of Enlightenment flowed over into economic, political, cultural, and legal life, thereby improving (a characteristic Enlightenment expression) the rest of society. This process was accelerated by the establishment of clubs like The Glasgow Literary Society and The Select Society in which professors, lawyers, aristocrats, merchants, clerics, and writers gathered to discuss pamphlets, essays, and books by ancient thinkers like Cicero and modern philosophers such as John Locke and Baron de Montesquieu.
Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations (1776) is the Scottish Enlightenment’s most famous product. But his book was deeply informed by a conviction shared by his colleagues and friends: that a new society was coming into being, one whose most prominent characteristic was its commercial character. For Scottish Enlightenment thinkers, the commercial society was a civilizational phenomenon that embodied the complexity and culture of which Hayek would speak two centuries later.
In writings like William Robertson’s History of America (1777) and Adam Ferguson’s History of Civil Society (1767), the prominence of urbanized commerce and ever-widening circles of trade in everyday life and their steady displacement of subsistence lifestyles dominated by agriculture constituted a decisive shift towards a greater civilizational level. In the minds of these authors, the spread of commerce and efforts to lower barriers to trade was opening the door for more people to improve their lives.
By this, the Scots did not only mean that economic growth through markets made people less poor, or even that such wealth was creating greater reserves of capital for investment on a scale unparalleled in history. Commercial society certainly generated these things. But commercial civilization, they held, also consisted of a multifaceted and shifting composite of interlinked social, economic, and legal norms, conditions, and institutions that had emerged, in Ferguson’s words, as “the result of human action, but not the execution of any human design.”
Put in today’s terms, no one planned this civilization of commerce from above. Instead, it emerged from the bottom-up as individuals exercised their natural liberty and pursued their own ends and, without intending to do so, contributed to the well-being of all. This is the core meaning of Smith’s famous turn of phrase, “the invisible hand,” used in the Wealth of Nations but also his Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) and Essays on Philosophical Subjects (1795). As a metaphor, it describes as much a historical process of civilizational transformation as the workings of the market.
Commerce and Modernity
This dimension of commercial civilization is especially well expressed in essays penned by David Hume from 1752 onwards. In these texts, Hume sketches a picture of civilizational progress being driven forward by the diminishment of trade barriers and monopolies and greater freedom for individuals to pursue their economic well-being. As he writes in “On Commerce” (1752, 1777):
The greatness of a state, and the happiness of its subjects, how independent soever they may be supposed in some respects, are commonly allowed to be inseparable with regard to commerce; and as private men receive greater security, in the possession of their trade and riches, from the power of the public, so the public becomes powerful in proportion to the opulence and extensive commerce of private men.
Note how Hume associates the expansion of commerce with private individuals realizing their independence, security, and happiness via an improvement in the overall well-being of society. The more commerce and market exchange spread within societies and across national boundaries, Hume states, the wealthier and happier people became:
Foreign trade, by its imports, furnishes materials for new manufactures; and by its exports, it produces labour in particular commodities, which could not be consumed at home. In short, a kingdom, that has a large import and export, must abound more with industry, and that employed upon delicacies and luxuries, than a kingdom which rests contented with its native commodities. It is, therefore, more powerful, as well as richer and happier. The individuals reap the benefit of these commodities, so far as they gratify the senses and appetites.
Hume’s use of the word “luxury” is important here. He wants his readers to understand that civilization and wealth should not be regarded as being inexorably in opposition to each other. On the contrary, they reinforced each other. This position was controversial as it clashed with the more traditional view, one with deep roots in Greek and Roman thought, that the ongoing diffusion of luxury and wealth tended to corrupt society and led to civilizational degradation.
For Hume, excessive wariness about luxury was a mistake. Not only did he consider material poverty as something undesirable. Hume saw the development of markets as facilitating and reflecting ever more complicated webs of relationships based on people’s freely chosen obligations. To the extent that these same markets relied upon wider commitments to property rights and the rule of law, they contributed to a more just society. These changes went alongside the emergence of more cultural and social possibilities as well as progress in knowledge in fields ranging from the natural sciences to aesthetics. “The same age,” Hume stated in his essay “Of Refinement in the Arts” (1752), “which produces great philosophers and politicians, renowned generals and poets, usually abounds with skillful weavers, and ship-carpenters.”
According to Hume, one cause of these dynamics was the spillover effects into other spheres of life of the sheer energy released by thriving commerce. “The spirit of the age,” Hume wrote “affects all the arts; and the minds of men, being once roused from their lethargy, and put into a fermentation, turn themselves on all sides, and carry improvements into every art and science.” In commercial societies, Hume stressed, “the mind acquires new vigor [and] enlarges its powers and faculties.” The results, he says, are spectacular:
Curiosity allures the wise; vanity the foolish; and pleasure both. Particular clubs and societies are everywhere formed: Both sexes meet in an easy and sociable manner; and the tempers of men, as well as their behavior, refine apace. So that, besides the improvements which they receive from knowledge and the liberal arts, it is impossible but they must feel an increase of humanity, from the very habit of conversing together, and contributing to each other’s pleasure and entertainment. Thus industry, knowledge, and humanity, are linked together by an indissoluble chain, and are found, from experience as well as reason, to be peculiar to the more polished, and, what are commonly denominated, the more luxurious ages.
Growth—Economic and Moral
It was therefore with great confidence that Hume looked forward to the steady decline of poverty and ignorance via what Hayek would call in his Constitution of Liberty over 200 years later “the creative powers of a free civilization.” Not everyone in Hume’s circles, however, viewed such matters with the same equanimity as he did.
The most prominent of such individuals was Adam Ferguson. He acknowledged and celebrated the advancements unleashed by the spread of commercial exchange and the escape from perpetual economic stagnation. Nevertheless, Ferguson also thought there was a downside to these changes.
Like other Scottish Enlightenment thinkers, Ferguson was deeply immersed in the philosophy, literature, and history of Greece and Rome. In later life, he even wrote a history of the fall of the Roman Republic. The language of virtue, Ferguson knew, was omnipresent in Greco-Roman thought. Moreover, like most Scottish Enlightenment thinkers, Ferguson was a believing Christian, and, in his case (like Robertson, Hutcheson, Reid, Blair, and others), a minister of the Church of Scotland.
It was consequently not surprising that, unlike Hume (who happily accepted the infidel label), Ferguson worried that enlargements of wealth and consumption might distract people from living the fullness of the good life that comes from pursuing and embracing all the virtues. “The boasted refinements,” Ferguson wrote in his History of Civil Society, “of the polished age, are not divested of danger. They open the door, perhaps, to disaster, as wide and accessible as any they have shut.”
Some of Ferguson’s fears about commercial civilization were shared by its greatest economic proponent. Adam Smith certainly believed, as recorded in his Lectures on Jurisprudence (1762-1763), that, “Whenever commerce is introduced into any country, probity and punctuality always accompany it.” At the same time, Smith thought that aspects of life in a commercial society presented its own challenges. Smith had famously made the specialization encouraged by the division of labor central to his economic account of how societies could break the cycle of poverty and grow economically. Yet he was concerned that economic specialization could lock many people into repetitive jobs that narrowed their outlook and closed their minds to higher possibilities.
However, this unease did not lead Smith to view commercial society as inherently corrupting. In the first place, Smith agreed with Hume that commerce actually encouraged specific virtues like prudence, courage, and deferred gratification. Second, like his teacher Francis Hutcheson, Smith regarded virtues as good in themselves and therefore good for all people at all times. For Smith, virtue was “excellence, something uncommonly great and beautiful.” The same words and their underlying logic would have been unhesitatingly echoed by ancients like Aristotle and Cicero or medieval thinkers like Thomas Aquinas.
That logic, Smith believed, was equally knowable by people who lived in a time of commerce. The conscious cultivation of virtue and the subsequent growth of personal character were central to Smith’s conception of human happiness. Education was part of the process for knowing how to become happy and develop in a manner that truly befits humans. So too, however, were the enhanced opportunities provided by commerce for greater numbers of people to acquire knowledge of such things. In Part VI of his Theory of Moral Sentiments, Smith presents the virtues of prudence, self-command, and benevolence as habits to cultivate in the new society emerging around him. These are not precisely the same habits of industry, knowledge, and humanity stressed by Hume. But they are eminently compatible.
Therein lies the genius of the civilization of commerce that the Scottish Enlightenment foresaw and helped bring into being. It possesses the qualities that Hayek ascribed to what he understood to be a civilized society that enable us to overcome our ignorance. The same civilization seamlessly combines flourishing in the economic, political, and moral aspects of human existence in ways harder to find in other social orders. That vision is and remains the Scottish Enlightenment’s great gift to those who seek to revive, protect, and extend the same civilization in our time.

